Dec 15, 2017 – Medical inadmissibility rules in Canada immigration applications violate a United Nations rights convention and are out of touch with Canadian values, according to a parliamentary committee report.
The Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration has recommended the repeal of the so-called ‘excessive demand’ clause, that stops people with disabilities and serious medical conditions from immigrating to Canada.
In a wide-ranging report, the damning report says the current rules ‘violate human rights’.
“Our immigration laws unjustifiably violate human rights of certain would-be newcomers to Canada and this is inconsistent with the modern values Canadian’s associate with contemporary human rights protections,” the report says.
Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen has already indicated the federal government could overhaul current medical inadmissibility rules.
The 40-year-old policy regularly creates some uncomfortable press headlines for Ottawa, and now Hussen has revealed all options are open, including completely scrapping what he called an ‘important and sensitive’ issue.
Hussen made the comments when he appeared before the parliamentary committee in November.
“From a principled perspective, the current excessive demand provision policy simply does not align with our country’s values of inclusion of person with disabilities in Canadian society,” said the chief of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada.
He also revealed the majority of provincial government representatives supported reviewing the policy, although there was some opposition because of the potential costs that would be incurred.
Federal government estimates suggest the policy saves $135 million out of five-year medical spending, which represents 0.1 per cent of the total provincial/territorial health budget.
Central to an immigration officer’s decision under current rules is whether health or social costs will be more than the average per person spend over five years. Applicants are also rejected if they stand to lengthen a waiting list resulting in delayed care for Canadian citizens or permanent residents.
Statistics show more than 220 people deemed inadmissible on medical grounds requested humanitarian consideration between 2013 and 2016. Some 91 per cent of them were successful.
Medical inadmissibility rules do not allow for candidates to commit to paying for their care, where the specific service is publicly funded. If the treatment required is not publicly funded, whether the applicant has the financial means to pay does become a consideration.
Risk Assessment: The Factors Immigration Officers Consider
When they assess the risk of an applicant, the officers will need to consider various factors. Some of the aspects that officers could consider include:
- Whether the person is suffering from a communicable or contagious disease
- Officers will typically need to assess this in the context of a threat to the travelling public and the community of destination
- In case the officers find that exercising precautions alone will not be able to guarantee that there will be no threat to anyone en route or in Canada, the officers will need to avoid issuing the permit
- Whether any protection or forewarning could be provided to the officials concerned and the public pertaining to a person who presents a health risk
- The severity of the person’s anticipated need for health or social services in relation to the demand for these services by Canadian residents
- The cost of the treatment of care – in case it is available
- The manner in which the coverage of the expenses incurred in Canada will take place e.g. insurance, family finances etc.
- The arrangements made for covering the treatment, the care and other expenses
- Whether the follow-up treatment will be necessary at home or in Canada
- Whether the follow-up treatment is available in the home country
- In case the follow-up treatment is not available in the home country, whether this situation will prevent the person from returning home
- Whether the person is likely to become self-supporting – in cases involving permanent residents and,
- Whether the risk exists that the person will require public assistance
Interested employers: Kindly contact us here to receive further information.
Interested candidates: Find out whether you qualify to Canada by completing our free on-line evaluation. We will provide you with our evaluation within 1-2 business days.
Read more news about Canada Immigration by clicking here.