Phone: +1 (514) 487-2011
  • CONTACT US
  • NEWS
  • LANGUAGES
    • English English
    • Français Français
    • Español Español
    • العربية العربية
    • Português Português
    • Русский Русский
    • עברית עברית

Canada Immigration and Visa Information. Canadian Immigration Services and Free Online Evaluation.

  • HOME
  • PROFILE
    • Immigration Attorney Profile – Colin Singer is an experienced authority on all aspects of Canadian immigration.
    • Authorized by the Government of Canada – Colin Singer has been a licensed immigration lawyer in good standing with a Canadian Law Society for over 25+ years.
    • Our Team – Our team of more than 25 licensed lawyers, immigration consultants and technical staff is ready to provide you with the immigration advice your need.
    • Why Hire an Immigration Lawyer? – The decision to move to Canada is life-changing. A lawyer can help maximize your chances of success and realize your immigration project.
    • Client References – The Quebec law society regulates the way lawyers are allowed to publish references from former clients.
    • Colin Singer Wikipedia Profile

    • Attorney Colin R. Singer

      Colin R. Singer is a licensed immigration lawyer in good standing with a Canadian Law Society during the past 25+ years.

    • Introduction to Immigration.ca Website


    • IMMIGRATION
      • Express Entry Overview
        • Express Entry Immigration Draws
        • Express Entry for Skilled Immigration
        • Comprehensive Ranking System
        • Invitations to Apply for Permanent Residence
      • Federal Skilled Worker
        • Who Qualifies as a Skilled Worker?
        • Eligible Occupations
        • How Can We Help You Immigrate?
      • Federal Skilled Trades
      • Canadian Experience Class

      • Provincial Immigration
        • Alberta
        • British Columbia
        • Manitoba
        • New Brunswick
        • Newfoundland
        • Northwest Territories
        • Nova Scotia
        • Ontario
        • Prince Edward Island
        • Saskatchewan
        • Yukon
      • Quebec Immigration
        • Quebec Skilled Worker
        • Quebec Business Immigration
        • Quebec Experience Program (PEQ)
      • Atlantic Immigration Pilot
        • Rural and Northern Immigration Pilot

      • Sponsorship Immigration
        • Sponsor Your Spouse or Common-Law Partner
        • Sponsor Your Parents & Grandparents
      • Criminal Inadmissibility
        • Impaired Driving Convictions
        • Individual Criminality
        • Organized Crime
        • Rehabilitation
        • Temporary Residence Permits
      • Canadian Citizenship
        • Benefits of Canadian Citizenship
        • Language Requirements
        • Residency Requirements
      • Refugee Immigration

      • BUSINESS
        • Canada offers the most established and widely-used investment-based immigration programs conferring permanent resident status


        • Canada Business Immigration
        • Provincial Entrepreneurs Programs
        • Self-Employed Programs
        • Start-up Visa
          • Eight Things to Know About Canada’s Start-Up Visa Program
        • International Business Immigration Programs
        • Buy a Business

        • Quebec Entrepreneur Program
        • Quebec Investor Program

        • Evaluation Form


          Fill out our FREE Immigration Evaluation Form and we will advise you within 48 Hours if you qualify to Immigrate to Canada.



          Click Here

        • TEMPORARY VISA
          • Canada Temporary Visa Overview – Have you made your decision to come to Canada as a temporary resident? Find out if you require a visa or an eTA.
          • Canada Visit/Tourist Visa – Do you want to visit your family and all the beautiful places Canada has to offer? You may need a tourist visa (TRV) to visit Canada.
          • Electronic Travel Authorization (eTA) – Are you a foreign national exempt from a TRV? You may need an eTA.
          • Canada Student Visa – You have been admitted to your chosen university? It is time to apply for a study permit.
          • Canada Work Permit – You found a sponsoring employer and you are eager to start your experience in Canada? Obtaining a work permit may be the solution for you.
          • Parents and Grandparents Super Visa – If you want your parents or grandparents to come visit for a longer period of time, a super visa may be the best solution.

          • STUDY
            • Why Study in Canada?
            • Student Direct Stream
            • Study in Canada News Articles
            • Study in Canada FAQ

            • Study in Canada: Steps
              • Step-by-Step Guide for International Students
              • How International Students Can Immigrate to Canada
              • Find Universities in Canada
              • Find Colleges in Canada
              • Get Admission to a University or College
              • Language Tests Converter
              • Financial Requirements
            • Work and Study in Canada
              • Work and Study in Canada
              • Internships and Co-Op Programs
              • On-Campus Work
              • Off-Campus Work
            • Work After Graduation
              • Work After Graduation
              • Post Graduation Work Permit
            • Studying in Quebec
              • Conditions to Qualify under PEQ – Graduate of Quebec Stream
              • How to Prove French Abilities under PEQ
              • Financial Requirements to Study in Quebec

            • EMPLOYMENT
              • Employment & Recruitment
                • Canada Priority Residence Program (CPRP)
                • Canada Employers
                • Job Search for Immigrants
                • Recruitment Team
              • Work Permits
                • LMIA-Based Work Permits
                • LMIA-Exemptions
                • Work Permit Exemptions
                • Open Work Permits
                • Global Skills Stream
                • International Mobility Program
                • International Experience Canada Program
                • Working in Quebec
                • Live-in Caregivers
              • The Application Process
                • How to Apply for a Work Permit?
                • What Happens After Submission?
                • How to Change or Extend Your Work Permit?
              • Working While Studying
                • Work on Campus
                • Work off Campus

              • Evaluation Form


                Fill out our FREE Immigration Evaluation Form and we will advise you within 48 Hours if you qualify to Immigrate to Canada.



                Click Here

              FREEEVALUATION
              Friday, 19 September 2014 / Published in Canada Immigration News Articles

              Seniors and the Generation Spending Gap


              Last Updated on January 24, 2019

              At age 89, Larry South would have been forgiven if he had chosen to retire on a sunny beach in Florida. Instead, the former MPP from Kingston, Ont., recently embarked on a political battle to overhaul the municipal property tax system. South had been growing increasingly concerned that elderly homeowners on fixed incomes were struggling to cope with rising property taxes because of the soaring value of their homes, while at the same time he fretted that young workers, with their stagnant wages, were being shut out of the housing market. And so south proposed replacing property taxes with a tax equal to 4.5 per cent of a homeowner’s yearly household income. Doing so would make it easier for young workers to afford the cost of owning a home, while struggling seniors he believed would be the biggest beneficiaries.

              But in his quest to change the tax system, he has come across an unlikely foe—his elderly friends. Like South, a former engineer who estimates he earns a retirement income that’s 30 to 40 per cent above the $86,000 household average in Kingston, many of his friends also pull in six-figure retirement incomes. Thanks to their high earnings, many would end up paying more in taxes under South’s plan than they do under the existing property tax system. Some, he says, resent the idea of paying more in tax than their younger, lower-income neighbours.

              South’s struggle to reform the property tax system, and the resistance he’s found among his affluent elderly friends, underscores what has been a remarkable shift in the nature of wealth in Canada. Seniors have long been considered society’s most vulnerable citizens, fragile pensioners on fixed incomes in need of a financial helping hand from both government and agile younger workers. That was true decades ago, but not anymore. Thanks to stock market booms, economic growth, a soaring real estate market and a major expansion in both private and government pension plans, today’s seniors are arguably the wealthiest generation in history. The changing fortunes of the elderly have been both swift and profound. In the 1970s, nearly 40 per cent of Canadian seniors lived in poverty. Today it’s five per cent, half the poverty rate of the working-age population and one-third the rate of poverty among children.

              Seniors have seen their wealth quadruple since 1984, according to a Bank of Montreal study released last month, far outpacing the growth of wealth among younger Canadians. The stunning transformation of the balance sheets of the elderly is thanks to a combination of financial discipline, public policy and good timing. Many of today’s seniors were the babies born in the aftermath of the Great Depression who learned to abhor debt and save aggressively. At the same time as they were socking away their hard-earned money, seniors got a major boost from the introduction of public benefits like Canada Pension Plan, Old Age Security and taxpayer-funded health care, which has helped push the poverty rate among elderly Canadians to one of the lowest in the Western world. In the 1980s, the typical senior was four times wealthier than the average 20-something.  

              Today’s seniors are now on average nine times richer than their millennial grandchildren. In fact, many of the trends and policies that have worked in favour of seniors have come at the expense of younger generations.

              That’s led some to warn of a coming generational war if public focus and resources aren’t shifted away from seniors to younger workers who are struggling far more than their parents ever did.

              Seniors may eventually become the only thing that drives the economy. Canadians aged 75 and older make up less than seven per cent of the population, but control more than a third of all financial assets in the country­­—roughly $1 trillion worth of stocks, bonds, mutual funds and cash. That figure doesn’t even include the money locked inside their homes, which have more than quadrupled in value since the 1980s. Far from running out of money, many seniors actually continue to save well into their golden years.

              The dramatic change in the fortunes of seniors, from the impoverished pensioners of yesterday to today’s wealthy retirees, is among the greatest policy success stories in Canadian history. Seniors’ incomes have jumped 40 per cent since 1984, says the Bank of Montreal, compared to 21 per cent for Baby Boomers and just three per cent for younger Canadians.

              Despite their affluence, seniors remain disproportionately the beneficiaries of government subsidies and tax breaks. German think tank Bertelsmann Foundation has called Canada among the “least inter-generationally just” countries in the world, with a troubling large gap between the poverty rates of seniors and children and a strong “elderly bias” among government programs and tax systems.

              Younger Canadians will inevitably be working longer than their parents and grandparents, given the age to qualify for CPP and OAS is rising from 65 to 67. More than 40 per cent of existing private sector defined pension plans, which have guaranteed a secure retirement for thousands of today’s retirees, are now largely closed off to new employees.

              At the same time, the end of mandatory retirement means more and more seniors are working long into their golden years. The employment rate for seniors has more than doubled since 1988, from 6.7 per cent to 13.2 per cent. That’s fine for those who need the extra income, but there is evidence that many seniors aren’t working because they need the money. While the share of seniors in the workforce has gone up, the share of those working full-time has actually gone down over the past 25 years, suggesting that many seniors aren’t staying in their jobs longer, but are instead turning to part-time jobs in retirement. 

              In 2013, the Municipal Retirees Organization Ontario studied public servants who continued working in retirement despite earning government pensions. More than half said their main motivation was to get out of the house. Only 16 per cent said they worked because they needed cash. It’s only a matter of time before generational conflicts over the workplace emerge in Canada as young people fight with their grandparents for the same jobs. When it comes to the tensions between young and old, however, there’s no greater battlefield than the housing market.

              Incredibly, the age gap is growing even when it comes to housing. Despite low interest rates that have allowed legions of young Canadians to qualify for large mortgages, it’s seniors who have experienced one of the biggest increases in home ownership of any age group. In 1981, just 66 per cent of those over the age of 70 owned their homes. Today it’s 72 per cent. Meanwhile, over the same period, the home ownership rate has actually gone down slightly among Canadians in their 30s and 40s.

              The fact that many young people are now digging themselves deeply into debt to buy a home is also engineering a massive transfer of wealth from young buyers to older sellers. Last year, University of Toronto geography professor Alan Walks mapped out a detailed geography of household wealth and debt in Canada. Walks found that cities with a high proportion of seniors also had higher levels of household debt. But when he looked closer, he found that it wasn’t the seniors who were deep in debt, but their younger neighbours, some of whom had debts worth more than 300 per cent of their incomes.

              Eric Swanson knows that phenomenon all too well. Recently, he and his wife made an offer on a small house in Victoria, a popular destination for Canadian retirees who have been flocking to Vancouver Island from oil-rich Alberta. “There are a lot of retirees also looking for small houses on small lots, so it’s making it a bit more difficult,” says Swanson, 31-year-old executive director of Generation Squeeze. Growing up, Swanson’s parents, both working professionals, seemed to have little trouble buying large houses close to downtown. It’s a different world today. “There’s a big part of us that feels we’re assuming a lot more risk than we may be able to handle down the road compared to the experiences of our parents,” he says.

              Others argue that the fact that many seniors have amassed sizable real estate wealth is less important than it seems since it means that plenty of seniors have become millionaires on paper, but with no way to cash out their housing wealth. Retirees who sell their suburban homes are often moving to the city, where they’re paying equally high prices for urban houses and condos with high maintenance fees, says Folda. “What we’ve seen really in the past decade is that the strategy of downsizing from grand houses to condominiums actually released very little liquidity to finance retirement,” she says.

              But the fact that some seniors have trouble cashing in their real estate windfalls pales in comparison to the issues facing young workers trying to afford their first home, says Gibbins. “I’d much rather be in the situation of trying to squeeze some financial gain out of a property than be somebody just starting out with a young family and trying to buy a house in Vancouver.”

              When it comes to housing, governments may be exacerbating the tensions between young and old. Several provinces offer property tax credits and subsidies that are only available to seniors. Earlier this year, Alberta launched a program that allows seniors to defer their property taxes until they sell their home or die—when the back taxes can then be taken out of their estate.

              Such preferential treatment isn’t limited to property taxes. Politicians of all stripes compete to promise new programs and tax breaks for seniors, while programs that would benefit younger Canadians, such as tuition and day-care subsidies, are considered too expensive for cash-strapped governments. Even programs that have proven uncontroversial when introduced for seniors can spark a political battle when governments try to expand them to younger Canadians. The Harper Conservatives introduced pension income splitting for seniors back in 2007, and heard no one object. But income splitting became a political nightmare when the government tried to expand it to families with children. Just as the proposal was seen to be supporting rich couples at the expense of poor single moms, the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives estimates that income splitting for seniors has disproportionately benefited the wealthiest retirees—allowing them to qualify for an extra $250 million in Old Age Security payments next year.

              It’s easy to blame seniors for stacking the deck in favour of their own generation. But in many ways, says Kershaw, it’s actually younger Canadians who are to blame for the lack of public support for their issues. Turnout among younger voters is notoriously low, so politicians naturally target their campaigns to the seniors who actually show up on election day. Many young Canadians also seem to support the idea of boosting spending on seniors—even at the expense of their own generation. Kershaw has polled Canadians, both young and old, asking them which age group should be the top priority for government. Not surprisingly, 70 per cent of seniors said politicians should focus on them. But he found that younger Canadians were just as likely to say governments should prioritize seniors as they were to say they should help their own generation. “Younger Canadians, like older Canadians, believe the stories about who is most vulnerable still in society,” says Kershaw. “These stories are increasingly outdated because they’re based on the big policy challenges of the past and a failure to recognize that the situation has really changed.”

              However, institutions that have tried to shift spending away from older Canadians often face a fierce public outcry. The B.C. government sparked protests when it announced it was scrapping the seniors discount on its ferry service. Seniors complained bitterly earlier this summer when Mount Allison University in New Brunswick said it would start charging them to attend university alongside their tuition-paying grandchildren. Calgary Mayor Naheed Nenshi has said he’s opposed to a plan by the city to scrap a discount that allows low-income seniors to pay $15 a year for public transit even though younger low-income residents pay $44 a month. “I can still not understand why someone living on $1,500 a month should be treated different if they’re 55 or 65,” Calgary alderman Jim Stevenson told council during the vote.

              Kershaw’s answer to the growing generational tensions is to try to turn Generation Squeeze into an organization for young Canadians that can rival the powerful seniors’ lobby group Carp (formerly the Canadian Association of Retired Persons). One idea the organization is taking directly from Carp is a membership card that would offer discounts on products and services, sort of a seniors discount for the under-45 set. Unlike Carp’s membership card, which offers deals on things like home insurance, fitness plans and travel discounts, a Generation Squeeze membership could include discounts on youth-friendly services like car-sharing programs and “mixer mortgages” that allow friends and roommates to co-own a house. By boosting the market clout of younger Canada, the organization hopes to force governments and corporations alike to start catering to their needs.

              But for there to be any meaningful change, governments will likely need to rethink the perks they give to their elderly voters and instead tailor their programs to those who really need the help, regardless of age. Gibbins thinks wealthy seniors may need to start covering more of the cost of their own health care to free up government resources for struggling younger workers. Despite the inevitable political blowback, governments may also need to start subjecting sacred seniors’ benefits like pension income-splitting or CPP and OAS to a “means test”—a sliding scale based on income. Today, a couple can earn a combined retirement income of $140,000 and still qualify for full Old Age Security. They can earn as much $230,000 before those benefits are clawed back entirely. In a study last year, the Fraser Institute proposed that lowering the claw back threshold for OAS benefits to $102,000 for a couple (or $51,000 per person) would free up $730 million in federal cash every year.

              The idea of also clawing back CPP for high-income retirees might seem inherently unfair given that those seniors paid into the system when they were working. But it wouldn’t be the first time affluent Canadians have paid more in taxes than they’ve received in benefits in order to support the less wealthy. “If we can just change that focus of vulnerability from the old to the young, I think we would really have accomplished something important,” says Gibbins

              The battle over how cash-strapped governments should divvy up their limited resources between young and old is only likely to heat up as the biggest wave of Baby Boomers enters retirement over the next decade. But it’s a battle worth waging—unless we want today’s seniors to be the last generation of Canadians living in retirement bliss.

              Source: Macleans

               

               

               


              Tagged under: Canada, retirement, seniors, tax

              Are you eligible to Immigrate to Canada?

              Find out if you are eligible to immigrate to Canada in less than 48 hours by filling our FREE Online Evaluation form. Click Here. 

               

              Close

              CANADA NEWS ARTICLES

              Recent Posts

              • Canada Creates New Immigration Streams For 90,000 Temporary Workers, International Graduates

                Canada Creates New Immigration Streams For 90,000 Temporary Workers, International Graduates

              • Canada Invites 266 In New PNP-Only Express Entry Draw

                Canada Invites 266 In New PNP-Only Express Entry Draw

              Site Search

              Podcasts

              Listen on Google Podcasts

              Subscribe to Our Newsletter

              Interested Candidates

              Find out whether you qualify to Canada by completing our free evaluation form We will provide you with our evaluation within 1-2 business days.

              • Free Evaluation Form

              Interested Agents

              Immigration.ca welcomes affiliations with qualified agents. Follow the link below to find out more.

              • Contact Us

              Interested Employers

              Kindly contact us here to receive further information.

              • Contact Us


              News

              Read more news about Canada Immigration.

              • Latest News

              Follow Immigration.ca

              facebook
              twitter
              Follow
              youtube
              linkedin

              What You Can Read Next

              Canada Creates New Immigration Streams For 90,000 Temporary Workers, International Graduates

              Canada Creates New Immigration Streams For 90,000 Temporary Workers, International Graduates

              14 April 2021 By Colin R. Singer in Canada Immigration News Articles, Coronavirus
              Canada Invites 266 In New PNP-Only Express Entry Draw

              Canada Invites 266 In New PNP-Only Express Entry Draw

              14 April 2021 By Colin R. Singer in Canada Immigration News Articles, Express Entry
              Alberta Immigration Invites 200 With Minimum CRS Of 302 In New Express Entry Draw

              Alberta Immigration Invites 200 With Minimum CRS Of 302 In New Express Entry Draw

              14 April 2021 By Colin R. Singer in Alberta News, Canada Immigration News Articles, Provincial News Articles
              Canada Enjoys Another Stellar Month For Immigration, Welcoming Nearly 24,000

              Canada Enjoys Another Stellar Month For Immigration, Welcoming Nearly 24,000

              14 April 2021 By Colin R. Singer in Canada Immigration News Articles, Coronavirus, Permanent Resident
              Ontario Immigration Issues 528 NOIs In New Express Entry Tech Draw

              Ontario Immigration Issues 528 NOIs In New Express Entry Tech Draw

              13 April 2021 By Colin R. Singer in Canada Immigration News Articles, Ontario-news, Provincial News Articles

              Canada Immigration

              • Home
              • Profile
              • Immigration
              • Temporary Visa
              • Study
              • Employment
              • Immigration.ca News

              Immigration.ca Network

              • Latest CRS Score
              • SkilledWorker
              • Investment Immigration
              • Buy a Business & Move to Canada
              • GRN Montreal
              • Canada Immigration News
              • Colin Singer

              Other Links

              • Agents and Affiliates
              • Find Our Affiliates
              • Canada Case Law
              • Immigration Wiki
              • Immigration Manuals
              • Operational Bulletins
              • International Business Programs
              • Universities Evaluation Form
              • Colleges Evaluation Form
              • Podcasts
              • Videos
              • eBook Series
              • Publications
              • Wikipedia
              Listen on Google Podcasts

              Help

              • Free Immigration Evaluation
              • Immigration Discussion Forum
              • Immigration FAQ
              • Contact Us
              • Telephone Consultation
              • Download Our New Mobile App
              • Link to Us
              • Sitemap
              • Disclaimer
              • Privacy Statement
              • Fraud Alert

              Contact

              Tel: +1 (514) 487-2011


              Fax: +1 (514) 487-2385



              Canadian Citizenship & Immigration Resource Center (CCIRC) Inc.

              Montreal Head Office
              4999 Ste-Catherine St. W, Suite 515
              Montreal, Quebec
              Canada, H3Z 1T3

              Toronto Office (By appointment)

              Mana Hosseini, B.A., M.B.A., JD
              President, Start Up Visa
              Business Advisory Group

              181 University Ave, Suite 2200
              Toronto, Ontario
              Canada, M5H 3M7

              Email: [email protected]
              Tel: +1 (514) 487-2011 
              Fax: +1 (416) 644-4675


              ©Copyright CCIRC Inc. 2020. All rights reserved.

              TOP
              Immigration.ca Logo
              • Free Evaluation
              • Home
              • Profile
                • Immigration Attorney Profile
                • Authorized by the Government of Canada
                • Our Team
                • Why Hire an Immigration Lawyer?
                • Client References
                • Colin Singer Wikipedia Profile
                • Back
              • Immigration
                • Canada Immigration Overview
                • Express Entry Overview
                  • Express Entry
                  • Federal Skilled Worker
                  • Federal Skilled Trades
                  • Canadian Experience Class
                  • Back
                • Provincial Immigration
                • Quebec Immigration
                • Business and Investment Immigration
                • Atlantic Immigration Pilot
                • Sponsorship Immigration
                • Refugee Immigration
                • Criminal Inadmissibility
                • Citizenship
                • Back
              • Temporary Visa
                • Canada Temporary Visa Overview
                • Canada Visit/Tourist Visa
                • Electronic Travel Authorization (eTA)
                • Canada Student Visa
                • Canada Work Permit
                • Parents and Grandparents Super Visa
                • Back
              • Business
                • Canada Business Immigration
                • Provincial Entrepreneurs Programs
                • Self-Employed Programs
                • Start-up Visa
                • International Business Immigration Programs
                • Buy a Business
                • Quebec Entrepreneurs Program
                • Quebec Investor Program
                • Back
              • Study
                • Canada Study Assessment
                • Why Study in Canada?
                • Student Direct Stream
                • Study in Canada: Steps
                  • Study in Canada: Steps
                  • Step-by-Step Guide for International Students
                  • How International Students Can Immigration to Canada
                  • Find Universities in Canada
                  • Find Colleges in Canada
                  • Get Admission to a University or College
                  • Language Tests Converter
                  • Financial Requirements
                  • Back
                • Work and Study in Canada
                  • Work and Study in Canada
                  • Internships and Co-Op Programs
                  • On-Campus Work
                  • Off-Campus Work
                  • Back
                • Work After Graduation
                  • Work After Graduation
                  • Post Graduation Work Permit
                  • Back
                • Studying in Quebec
                  • Conditions to Qualify under PEQ – Graduate of Quebec Stream
                  • How to Prove French Abilities under PEQ
                  • Financial Requirements to Study in Quebec
                  • Back
                • Study in Canada News Articles
                • Study in Canada FAQ
                • Back
              • Employment
                • Employment & Immigration Programs
                  • Employment & Recruitment
                  • Canada Priority Residence Program (CPRP)
                  • Canada Employers
                  • Job Search for Immigrants
                  • Back
                • Work Permits
                  • Work Permits
                  • LMIA-Based Work Permits
                  • LMIA-Exemptions
                  • Work Permit Exemptions
                  • Open Work Permits
                  • Global Skills Stream
                  • International Mobility Program
                  • International Experience Canada Program
                  • Working in Quebec
                  • Live-in Caregivers
                  • Back
                • The Application Process
                  • How to Apply for a Work Permit?
                  • What Happens After Submission?
                  • How to Change or Extend Your Work Permit?
                  • Back
                • Working While Studying
                  • Work on Campus
                  • Work off Campus
                  • Back
                • Back
              Free Immigration Evaluation
              Click Here

              Free Immigration Evaluation Forms

              • Skilled Worker Assessment
              • Business Immigration Assessment
              • Start-up Visa Assessment
              • Family Class Sponsorship Assessment
              • Canada Study Assessment
              • Telephone Consultation
              Send this to a friend